In
high-level reading books, we can often sift through the text to find purposeful
author choices, and the power/resistance that characters have. Sometimes, characters mis-understand the
level of power they have, and other times they fight the power of others.
Hidden in XYZ-level books such as The Stolen Party by Liliana Heker are
important lessons that can be found by closely reading with a specific lens.
When I did this, I noticed small yet important details that contributed greatly
to my conclusions about The Stolen Party.
The
first lens I used was word choice. One section of The Stolen Party that I
closely examined was a part where Rosaura, a poor maid’s daughter, is preparing
for a party at her rich friend Liliana’s house. Although her mother tries to
convince her otherwise the night before, Rosaura believes that Liliana is
friends with her, and has invited her to the party as a guest. The morning of
the party, Rosaura is very confident because she looks so nice. The words and
phrases that the author chose include “Terribly Pretty,” “Lovely,” “Firm step,”
and “Admired herself.” Rosaura’s confidence affects how she acts, and she goes
into the party that way. This confidence only grows throughout the party as
Rosaura wins all of the games, helps out with the cake, and becomes the
magician’s helper.
I
re-read the sections with a different lens- power. Some of what I noticed the
first time connected to power. For example, in the beginning when Rosaura
argues with her mother, she knows that her mom has more power, yet she is
resisting that advantage. The next scene showed Rosaura allowing herself power
by thinking that she looks pretty. We can tell that Luciana has power over
Rosaura- not only because she is the host of the party, but also because
Rosaura’s mother works for Luciana’s family. The last scene of The Stolen
Party is when SeƱora Ines offers Rosaura money instead of a gift like every
other guest. This is when Rosaura realizes that she was not a guest at the
party. We know that Rosaura has the power to take the money, but she is also
giving up her power by taking the money.
In
real life, power is resisted all of the time. Whenever someone feels like they
are less powerful than someone else, they feel intimidated and upset,
especially when that power is used against them. Sometimes this is a small
resistance, such as talking back to your parents, but others are resistances
such as rebellion. We’ve seen both in our books, and both in our world too.
No comments:
Post a Comment